Provider Directory Scorecards

Rank Data source N Invalid Ambiguous Inconsistent Chart
1 Oakland Southfield Physicians 944 2.01% 5.08% 1.80%
2 Corewell Health 16,409 0.32% 11.18% 0.67%
3 American Board of Osteopathic Medicine 12,804 0.02% 13.00% 0.13%
4 Ascension Health 15,462 2.17% 13.18% 0.62%
5 Trinity Health-Michigan 7,577 1.66% 11.90% 2.82%
6 Meridian Health Plan of Michigan 29,776 0.49% 18.30% 0.37%
7 Henry Ford Health System 17,366 0.48% 7.79% 11.63%
8 Tenet Health 11,547 3.38% 8.53% 8.89%
9 Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services 18,644,612 1.31% 11.48% 16.29%
10 Molina Healthcare 420,270 1.78% 15.01% 16.99%
11 Prime Healthcare 10,210 2.53% 12.01% 19.55%
12 McLaren Health Care 3,578 1.01% 10.31% 25.10%
13 Blue Cross Complete of Michigan 89,574 1.33% 16.57% 23.13%
14 University of Michigan Sparrow 🚫

Key:

  • N - Number of Provider/Location or Practice/Location combinations represented in source data
  • Invalid - Address is not recognized by the USPS.
  • Ambiguous - Address is incomplete. Needs a suite number or other detail to be precise.
  • Inconsistent - Using different label to represent the same location, e.g. If 7 records show "101 N Main" and 3 show "101 North Main St", the majority (7) are considered canonical, and 3 out of 10 (30%) would show as "Inconsistent".
  • 🚫 - Data source does not provide location information

Data supplied by Provider Harbor, current as of 2026-07-18.

Please don't shoot the messenger.
This article contains easily verifiable observations based on publicly-accessible data sources illustrating the ubiquity of provider directory management challenges. It is intended for educational purposes in the hope that it provides information that leads to better quality provider data across the healthcare industry. For detail on the data represented here, please email phscorecards@informationsoftworks.com.